"If they hear not Moses and the Prophets, neither will
they be persuaded, though one rose from the dead." Luke 16:31.
1. How strange a paradox is this! How contrary to the common apprehension
of men! Who is so confirmed in unbelief as not to think, "If one came to
me from the dead, I should be effectually persuaded to repent?" But this
passage affords us a more strange saying: (Luke 16:13:) "Ye cannot serve
God and mammon." "No! Why not? Why cannot we serve both?" will a true servant
of mammon say. Accordingly, the Pharisees, who supposed they served God,
and did cordially serve mammon, derided him: _exemyktErizon_. A word expressive
of the deepest contempt. But he said, (Luke 16:15,) "Ye are they who justify
yourselves before men; but God knoweth your hearts: And that which is highly
esteemed among men, is (very commonly) an abomination before God:" A terrible
proof of which our Lord subjoins in the remaining part of the chapter.
2. But is the subsequent account merely a parable, or a real history?
It has been believed by many, and roundly asserted, to be a mere parable,
because of one or two circumstances therein, which are not easy to be accounted
for. In particular, it is hard to conceive, how a person in hell could
hold conversation with one in paradise. But, admitting we cannot account
for this, will it overbalance an express assertion of our Lord: "There
was," says our Lord, "a certain rich man." -- Was there not? Did such a
man never exist? "And there was a certain beggar named Lazarus."- -Was
there, or was there not? Is it not bold enough, positively to deny what
our blessed Lord positively affirms? Therefore, we cannot reasonably doubt,
but the whole narration, with all its circumstances, is exactly true. And
Theophylact (one of the ancient commentators on the Scriptures) observes
upon the text, that, "according to the tradition of the Jews, Lazarus lived
I purpose, with God's assistance, First, to explain this history; Secondly,
to apply it; and, Thirdly, to prove the truth of that weighty sentence
with which it is concluded, namely, "If they hear not Moses and the Prophets,
neither will they be persuaded, though one rose from the dead."
I. 1. And, First, I will endeavour, with God's assistance, to explain
this history. "There was a certain rich man;" and, doubtless, on that very
account, highly esteemed among men, -- "who was clothed in purple and fine
linen;" and, consequently, esteemed the more highly, both as appearing
suitably to his fortune, and as an encourager of trade; -- "and fared sumptuously
every day." Here was another reason for his being highly esteemed, -- his
hospitality and generosity, -- both by those who frequently sat at his
table, and the tradesmen that furnished it.
2. "And there was a certain beggar;" one in the lowest line of human
infamy; "named Lazarus," according to the Greek termination; in Hebrew,
Eleazer. From his name we may gather, that he was of no mean family, although
this branch of it was, at present, so reduced. It is probable he was well
known in the city; and it was no scandal to him to be named. -- "Who was
laid at his gate;" although no pleasing spectacle; so that one might wonder
he was suffered to lie there; -- "full of sores;" of running ulcers; --
"and desiring to be fed with the crumbs which fell from the rich man's
table." So the complicated affliction of poverty, pain, and want of bread,
lay upon him at once! But it does not appear that any creature took the
least notice of the despicable wretch! Only "the dogs came and licked his
sores:" All the comfort which this world afforded him!
3. But see the change! "The beggar died:" Here ended poverty and pain:
-- "And was carried by angels;" nobler servants than any that attended
the rich man; -- "into Abraham's bosom:" -- So the Jews commonly termed
what our blessed Lord styles paradise; the place "where the wicked cease
from troubling, and where the weary are at rest;" the receptacle of holy
souls, from death to the resurrection. It is, indeed, very generally supposed,
that the souls of good men, as soon as they are discharged from the body,
go directly to heaven; but this opinion has not the least foundation in
the oracles of God: On the contrary, our Lord says to Mary, after the resurrection,
"Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended to my Father" in heaven. But he
had been in paradise, according to his promise to the penitent thief: "This
day shalt thou be with me in paradise." Hence, it is plain, that paradise
is not heaven. It is indeed (if we may be allowed the expression) the antechamber
of heaven, where the souls of the righteous remain till, after the general
judgment, they are received into glory.
4. But see the scene change again! "The rich man also died." -- What!
must rich men also die? Must they fall "like one of the people?" Is there
no help? A rich man in London, some years ago, when the physician told
him he must die, gnashed his teeth, and clenched his fist, and cried out
vehemently, "God, God, I won't die!' But he died with the very words in
his mouth. -- "And was buried;" doubtless, with pomp enough, suitably to
his quality; although we do not find that there was then, in all the world,
that exquisite instance of human folly, that senseless, cruel mockery of
a poor putrifying carcass, what we term lying in state!
5. And in hell he lifted up his eyes." -- O, what a change! How is the
mighty fallen! But the word which is here rendered hell does not always
mean the place of the damned. It is, literally, the invisible world; and
is of very wide extent, including the receptacle of separate spirits, whether
good or bad. But here it evidently means, that region of hades where the
souls of wicked men reside, as appears from the following words, "Being
in torment;" -- "in order," say some, "to atone for the sins committed
while in the body, as well as to purify the soul from all its inherent
sin." Just so, the eminent heathen poet, near two thousand years ago: --
Multa diu concreta modis inolescere miris,
Ergo exercentur poenis --
-- Aliae panduntur inanes
Suspensae ad ventos: Aliis sub gurgite vasto
Infectum eluitur scelus, aut exuritur igni._
[This quotation from Virgil (Aeneid vi.737-742) is thus translated by
"Ev'n when those bodies are to death resign'd,
Some old inherent spots are left behind;
A sullying tincture of corporeal stains
Deep in the substance of the soul remains.
Thus are her splendours dimm'd, and crusted o'er
With those dark vices that she knew before.
For this the souls a various penance pay,
To purge the taint of former crimes away.
Some in the sweeping breezes are refined,
And hung on high to whiten in the wind:
Some cleanse their stains beneath the gushing streams,
And some rise glorious from the searching flames." -- Edit.]
See the near resemblance between the ancient and the modern purgatory!
Only in the ancient, the heathen purgatory, both fire, water, and air,
were employed in expiating sin, and purifying the soul; whereas in the
mystic purgatory, fire alone is supposed sufficient both to purge and expiate.
Vain hope! No suffering, but that of Christ, has any power to expiate sin;
and no fire, but that of love, can purify the soul, either in time or in
6. "He seeth Abraham afar off." -- Far, indeed! as far as from hell
to paradise! Perhaps, "ten-fold the length of this terrene." But how could
this be? I cannot tell: But it is by no means incredible. For who knows
"how far an angel kens," or a spirit divested of flesh and blood? -- "And
Lazarus in his bosom." It is well known that, in the ancient feasts among
the Jews, as well as the Romans, the guests did not sit down at the table,
as it is now the custom to do; but lay on couches, each having a pillow
at his left side, on which he supported his elbow; and he that sat next
him, on the right side, was said to lie in his bosom. It was in this sense
that the Apostle John lay in his Master's bosom. Accordingly, the expression
of Lazarus lying in Abraham's bosom implies that he was in the highest
place of honour and happiness.
7. "And he cried, and said, Father Abraham, have mercy on me." -- Thou
fool! what can Abraham do? What can any creature, yea, all the creation
do, to break the bars of the bottomless pit? Whoever would escape from
the place of torment, let him cry to God, the Father of mercy! Nay, but
the time is past! Justice now takes place, and rejoices over mercy! --
"And send Lazarus, that he may dip the tip of his finger in water, and
cool my tongue; for I am tormented in this flame!" How exceeding modest
a request is this! He does not say, "That he may take me out of this flame."
He does not ask, "That he may bring me a cup of water, or as much as he
might hold in the palm of his hand;" but barely, "That he may dip" were
it but "the tip of his finger in water, and cool my tongue." No! It cannot
be! No mercy can enter within the shades of hell!
8. "But Abraham said, Son, remember that thou in thy lifetime receivedst
thy good things, and likewise Lazarus evil things; but now he is comforted,
and thou art tormented." Perhaps these words may supply us with an answer
to an important question: How came this rich man to be in hell? It does
not appear that he was a wicked man, in the common sense of the word; that
he was a drunkard, a common swearer, a Sabbath-breaker, or that he lived
in any known sin. It is probable he was a Pharisee; and as such was, in
all the outward parts of religion, blameless. How then did he come into
"the place of torment?" If there was no other reason to be assigned, there
is a sufficient one implied in those words, ("he that hath ears to hear,
let him hear!") "Thou in thy lifetime receivedst thy good things;" -- the
things which thou hadst chosen for thy happiness. Thou hadst set thy affection
on things beneath: And thou hadst thy reward: Thou didst receive the portion
which thou hadst chosen, and canst have no portion above. "And likewise
Lazarus evil things." Not his evil things; for he did not choose them.
But they were chosen for him by the wise providence of God: And "now he
is comforted, while thou art tormented."
9. "But beside all this, there is a great gulf fixed:" -- A great chasm,
a vast vacuity Can any tell us what this is? What is the nature, what are
the bounds, of it? Nay, none of the children of men; none but an inhabitant
of the invisible world. -- "So that they who would pass from hence to you
cannot; neither can they pass to us, that would come from thence." Undoubtedly
a disembodied spirit could pass through any space whatever. But the will
of God, determining that none should go across that gulf, is a bound which
no creature can pass.
10. Then he said, "I pray thee therefore, father, that thou wouldst
send him to my father's house; for I have five brethren; that he may testify
unto them, lest they also come into this place of torment." (Luke 16:27,
28.) Two entirely different motives have been assigned for this extraordinary
request. Some ascribe it wholly to self-love, to a fear of the bitter reproaches
which, he might easily suppose, his brethren would pour upon him, if, in
consequence of his example, and perhaps advice, they came to the same place
of torment. Others have imputed it to a nobler motive. They suppose, as
the misery of the wicked will not be complete till the day of judgment,
so neither will their wickedness. Consequently, they believe that, till
that time, they may retain some sparks of natural affection; and they,
not improbably, imagine that this may have occasioned his desire to prevent
their sharing his own torment.
11. "Abraham saith unto him, They have Moses and the Prophets: let them
hear them." (Luke 16:29.) "And he said, Nay, father Abraham; but if one
went to them from the dead, they will repent." Who would not be of the
same opinion? Might not any one reasonably suppose that a message solemnly
delivered by one that came from the dead must have an irresistible force?
Who would not think, "I myself could not possibly withstand such a preacher
II. This I conceive to be the meaning of the words. I will now endeavour,
with the help of God, to apply them. And I beseech you, brethren. while
I am doing this, "to suffer the word of exhortation." The more closely
these things are applied to your souls, the more ye may profit thereby.
1. "There was a certain rich man:" -- And it is no more sinful to be
rich than to be poor. But it is dangerous beyond expression. Therefore,
I remind all of you that are of this number, that have the conveniences
of life, and something over that ye walk upon slippery ground. Ye continually
tread on snares and deaths. Ye are every moment on the verge of hell! "It
is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for you to
enter in the kingdom of heaven." -- "Who was clothed in purple and fine
linen." And some may have a plea for this. Our Lord mentions them that
"dwell in kings' houses," as wearing gorgeous, that is, splendid, apparel,
and does not blame them for it. But certainly this is no plea for any that
do not dwell in kings' houses. Let all of them, therefore, beware how they
follow his example who is "lifting up his eyes in hell!" Let us follow
the advice of the Apostle, being "adorned with good works, and with the
ornament of a meek and quiet spirit."
2. "He fared sumptuously every day." -- Reconcile this with religion
who can. I know how plausibly the prophets of smooth things can talk in
favour of hospitality; of making our friends welcome: of keeping a handsome
table, to do honour to religion; of promoting trade, and the like. But
God is not mocked: He will not be put off with such pretences as these.
Whoever thou art that sharest in the sin of this rich man, were it no other
than "faring sumptuously every day," thou shalt as surely be a sharer in
his punishment, except thou repent, as if thou wert already crying for
a drop of water to cool thy tongue!
3. "And there was a certain beggar named Lazarus, who was laid at his
gate, full of sores, and desiring to be fed with the crumbs which fell
from the rich man's table." (Luke 16:20, 21.) But it seems both the rich
man and his guests were too religious to relieve common beggars! -- a sin
of which pious Mr. H. so earnestly warns his readers; and an admonition
of the same kind I have read on the gate of the good city of Winchester!
I wish the gentlemen who placed it there had seen a little circumstance
which occurred some years since. At Epworth, in Lincolnshire, the town
where I was born, a beggar came to a house in the market-place, and begged
a morsel of bread, saying she was very hungry. The master bid her be gone,
for a lazy jade. She called at a second, and begged a little small beer,
saying she was very thirsty. She had much the same answer. At a third door
she begged a little water; saying she was very faint. But this man also
was too conscientious to encourage common beggars. The boys, seeing a ragged
creature turned from door to door, began to pelt her with snow-balls. She
looked up, lay down, and died! Would you wish to be the man who refused
that poor wretch a morsel of bread, or a cup of water? -- "Moreover the
dogs came and licked his sores:" Being more compassionate than their master.
-- "And it came to pass, that the beggar died, and was carried of angels
into Abraham's bosom." Hear this, all ye that are poor in this world. Ye
that, many times, have not food to eat, or raiment to put on; ye that have
not a place where to lay your head, unless it be a cold garret, or a foul
and damp cellar! Ye are now reduced to "solicit the cold hand of charity."
Yet lift up your load; it shall not always be thus. I love you, I pity
you, I admire you, when "in patience ye possess your souls." Yet I cannot
help you. But there is One that can, -- the Father of the fatherless, and
the Husband of the widow. "The poor crieth unto the Lord; and he heareth
him, and delivereth him out of all his troubles." Yet a little while, if
ye truly turn to him, his angels shall carry you into Abraham's bosom.
There ye shall "hunger no more, and thirst no more;" ye shall feel no more
sorrow or pain; but "the Lamb shall wipe away all tears from your eyes,
and lead you forth beside fountains of living waters."
4. But see, the scene is changed! "The rich man also died." What? In
spite of his riches? Probably sooner than he desired. For how just is that
word, "O death, how bitter art thou to a man that is at rest in the midst
of his possessions!" However, if that would be a comfort, "he was buried."
But how little did it signify, whether he was laid under a lofty monument,
Graves with bending osier bound,
That nameless heave the crumbled ground!
And what followed? "In hell he lifted his eyes." This, it is certain,
ye need not do. God does not require it of you: "He willeth not that any
should perish." Ye cannot, unless by your own wilful choice, -- intruding
into those regions of woe, which God did not prepare for you, but for "the
devil and his angels."
5. See the scene change again! "He seeth Abraham afar off, and Lazarus
in his bosom." And he knew him; although, perhaps, he had only cast a glance
at him while he "lay at his gates." Is any of you in doubt whether we shall
know one another in the other world? Here your doubts may receive a full
solution. If a soul in hell knew Lazarus in paradise, as far off as he
was, certainly those that are together in paradise will perfectly know
6. "And he cried, and said, Father Abraham, have mercy upon me!" --
I do not remember, in all the Bible, any prayer made to a saint, but this.
And if we observe who made it, -- a man in hell, -- and with what success,
we shall hardly wish to follow the precedent. O let us cry for mercy to
God, not to man! And it is our wisdom to cry now, while we are in the land
of mercy; otherwise it will be too late! -- "I am tormented in this flame!"
Tormented, observe, not purified. Vain hope, that fire can purify a spirit!
As well might you expect water to cleanse the soul, as fire. God forbid
that you or I should make the trial!
7. And "Abraham said, Son, remember:" -- Mark, how Abraham accosts a
damned spirit: And shall we behave with less tenderness to any of the children
of God, "because they are not of our opinion?" -- "Thou in thy lifetime
receivedst thy good things." O, beware it be not your case! Are not the
things of the world "thy good things?" -- the chief objects of thy desire
and pursuit? Are they not thy chief joy? If so, thou art in a very dangerous
state; in the very condition which Dives was in upon earth! Do not then
dream that all is well, because thou art "highly esteemed among men;" because
thou doest no harm, or doest much good, or attendest all the ordinances
of God. What is all this, if thy soul cleaves to the dust; if thy heart
is in the world; if thou lovest the creature more than the Creator?
8. How striking are the next words! "Beside all this, between us and
you there is a great gulf fixed; so that they who would pass from us to
you cannot; neither can they pass to us, that would come from thence."
This was the text which occasioned the epitaph on a right honourable infidel
and gamester: --
Here lies a dicer; long in doubt
If death could kill the soul, or not:
Here ends his doubtfulness; at last
Convinced; -- but,ah! the die is cast!
But, blessed be God, your die is not cast yet. You are not passed the
great gulf, but have it still in your power to choose whether you will
be attended by angels or fiends when your soul quits its earthly mansion.
Now stretch out your hand to eternal life or eternal death! And God says,
"Be it unto thee even as thou wilt!"
9. Being repulsed in this, he makes another request: "I pray thee, send
him to my father's house; for I have five brethren; that he may testify
to them." It is not impossible that other unhappy spirits may wish well
to the relations they have left behind them. But this is the accepted time
for them, as well as for us. Let us then address them ourselves; and let
us beg our living friends to give us all the help they can, without waiting
for assistance from the inhabitants of another world. Let us earnestly
exhort them to use the helps they have; to "hear Moses and the Prophets."
We are indeed apt to think, like that unhappy spirit, "If one went to them
from the dead, they will repent." "But Abraham said, If they hear not Moses
and the Prophets, neither will they be persuaded though one rose from the
III. 1. I am, in the Third place, to prove the truth of this weighty
sentence; which I will do, First, briefly, and then more at large.
And, First, to express the matter briefly: It is certain that no human
spirit, while it is in the body, can persuade another to repent; can work
in him an entire change, both of heart and life; a change from universal
wickedness, to universal holiness. And suppose that spirit discharged from
the body, it is no more able to do this than it was before: No power less
than that which created it at first can create any soul anew. No angel,
much less any human spirit, whether in the body or out of the body, can
bring one soul "from darkness to light, and from the power of Satan unto
God." It might very possibly fright him to death, or to the belief of any
speculative truth; but it could not frighten him into spiritual life. God
alone can raise those that are "dead in trespasses and sins."
2. In order to prove more at large, that if men "hear not Moses and
the Prophets, neither will they be" effectually "persuaded" to repent,
"though one rose from the dead," I will propose a case of this kind, with
all the advantages that can be conceived. Suppose, then, one that does
not "hear Moses and the Prophets," that does not believe the Scripture
to be of God, to be fast asleep in his bed, and suddenly to awake while
the clock was just striking one. He is surprised to observe the chamber
as light as if it were noon-day. He looks up, and sees one whom he perfectly
knew standing at his bed-side. Though a little surprised at first, he quickly
recollects himself, and has the courage to ask, "Are not you my friend,
who died at such a time?" He answers, "I am. I am come from God, with a
message to you. You have often wished you could see one risen from the
dead; and said, then you would repent. You have your wish; and I am ordered
to inform you, you are seeking death in the error of your life. If you
die in the state you are in now, you will die eternally. I warn you, in
His name, that the Scriptures are the real word of God; that from the moment
you die, you will be remarkably happy, or unspeakably miserable; that you
cannot be happy hereafter, unless you are holy here; which cannot be, unless
you are born again. Receive this call from God! Eternity is at hand. Repent,
and believe the gospel!" Having spoken these words, he vanishes away; and
the room is dark as it was before.
3. One may easily believe, it would be impossible for him not to be
convinced for the present. He would sleep no more that night; and would,
as soon as possible, tell his family what he had seen and heard. Not content
with this, he would be impatient to tell it to his former companions. And,
probably, observing the earnestness with which he spoke, they would not
then contradict him. They would say to each other, "Give him time to cool;
then he will be a reasonable man again."
4. Now, it is constantly found, that impressions made on the memory
gradually decay; that they grow weaker and weaker in process of time, and
the traces of them fainter and fainter. So it must be in this case; which
his companions observing, would not fail to seize the opportunity. They
would speak to this effect: "It was a strange account you gave us some
time since; the more so,because we know you to be a sensible man, and not
inclined to enthusiasm. But, perhaps, you have not fully considered, how
difficult it is, in some cases, to distinguish our dreams from our waking
thoughts. Has anyone yet been able to find out an infallible criterion
between them? Is it not then possible, that you may have been asleep when
this lively impression was made on your mind?" When he had been brought
to think, possibly it might be a dream; they would soon persuade him, probably
it was so; and not long after, to believe, it certainly was a dream. So
little would it avail, that one came from the dead!
5. It could not be expected to be otherwise. For what was the effect
which was wrought upon him? (1.) He was exceedingly frightened: (2.) This
fright made way for a deeper conviction of the truth then declared: But
(3.) his heart was not changed. None but the Almighty could effect this.
Therefore (4.) the bias of his soul was still set the wrong way; he still
loved the world, and, consequently, wished that the Scripture was not true.
How easily then, as the fright wore off, would he again believe what he
wished! The conclusion then is plain and undeniable. If men "hear not Moses
and the Prophets, neither will they be persuaded" to repent and believe
the gospel, "though one rose from the dead."
6. We may add one consideration more, which brings the matter to a full
issue. Before, or about the same time, that Lazarus was carried into Abraham's
bosom, another Lazarus, the brother of Martha and Mary, was actually raised
from the dead. But were even those who believed the fact persuaded to repent?
So far from it, that "they took counsel to kill Lazarus," as well as his
Master! Away then with the fond imagination, that those who "hear not Moses
and the Prophets, would be persuaded, though on from the dead!"
7. From the whole we may draw this general conclusion. That standing
revelation is the best means of rational conviction; far preferable to
any of those extraordinary means which some imagine would be more effectual.
It is therefore our wisdom to avail ourselves of this; to make full use
of it; so that it may be a lantern to our feet, and a light in all our
paths. Let us take care that our whole heart and life be conformable thereto;
that it be the constant rule of all our tempers, all our words, and all
our actions. So shall we preserve in all things the testimony of a good
conscience toward God; and when our course is finished, we too shall be
"carried by angels into Abraham's bosom." Birmingham, March 25, 1788.
[Edited by Andrew Zirschky, student at Northwest Nazarene
College (Nampa, ID), with corrections by George Lyons for the Wesley Center
for Applied Theology.]